16-Year-Old Held Without Bail in Queens Killing of 13-Year-Old, Judge Denies Leniency Requests

A 16-year-old boy accused of fatally shooting a 13-year-old outside a Dunkin’ Donuts in Queens has been ordered to be held without bail following his arraignment on murder charges. During the court proceedings, which occurred on Saturday, Judge Eugene Bowen highlighted that despite the teen’s described struggles with asthma and ADHD, he was fully aware of the seriousness of his actions when he allegedly killed Sanjay Samuel.

In an emotional courtroom atmosphere, family members of the accused were seen visibly distressed, some requiring assistance from court personnel. As the prosecutor, Assistant District Attorney Andres Sanchez, provided details about the chilling incident, one family member voiced their shock at the gravity of the charges against the teenager.

The defendant, whose identity has not been publicly revealed due to his age, turned himself in to authorities at the 105th Precinct. The violent encounter took place in Cambria Heights around 8:20 a.m. on September 22, 2025, when the alleged shooter approached Samuel and his friends on a Razor scooter. Sanjay was reportedly engaged in conversation with classmates when the assailant brandished a firearm, causing chaos as the group scattered before engaging in a physical altercation.

Surveillance footage captured the initial confrontation, where the defendant allegedly pistol-whipped Samuel multiple times before fatally shooting him in the back of the head. This altercation occurred in a busy intersection frequented by pedestrians going to work and students headed to school, as noted by the prosecutor, highlighting the brazen nature of the attack.

Sanjay succumbed to his injuries two days later while on life support, a tragic turn of events that has drawn attention to ongoing concerns about gun violence in urban environments. The teenager is currently facing charges of second-degree murder and weapon possession, with potential sentencing ranging from 25 years to life imprisonment upon conviction.

Notably, conversations surrounding potential gang affiliations have emerged, as both the shooter and the victim had reportedly displayed connections to gang culture. However, Sanjay’s father has rebutted claims regarding his son’s gang involvement, stressing his child’s dedication to maintaining a structured life.

The courtroom mood was tense as defense attorney Darren Fields appealed for leniency, emphasizing the teenager’s struggles. Judge Bowen, however, firmly stated that the accused’s age does not absolve him of responsibility for his actions.

Queens District Attorney Melinda Katz condemned the violent incident, reiterating the pressing issue of gun violence that claims the lives of many young people and jeopardizes public safety. The ramifications of this case extend beyond the individuals directly involved, raising broader questions about youth violence and its societal impact. Further proceedings will determine the legal consequences that the accused will face in the coming months.