Zohran Mamdani explains his change of stance on the specialized high school admissions exam after previously opposing it.
As a graduate of the Bronx High School of Science, one of New York City’s most prestigious specialized high schools, Zohran Mamdani has previously been an advocate for eliminating the contentious Specialized High Schools Admissions Test (SHSAT) used for admissions to these elite institutions. However, during the recent primary campaign, Mamdani shifted his position, indicating a more nuanced understanding of the challenges facing the city’s education system.
In a discussion, Mamdani elaborated on his revised stance, explaining that the conversation surrounding the SHSAT is inextricably linked to broader issues of school segregation. He acknowledged the complexity of reforming the educational landscape, emphasizing the necessity to address systemic inequalities that influence student admissions. Mamdani voiced concerns about the significant disparities present in New York City’s specialized high schools, which have consistently demonstrated low acceptance rates for Black and Hispanic students.
Recent statistics reveal that while Black and Hispanic students constitute approximately two-thirds of the public school enrollment, they accounted for only 3% and 6.9% of offers to specialized high schools this year. These sobering figures highlight a persistent trend of inequality, undermining previous efforts aimed at diversifying the student bodies of these esteemed institutions.
Mamdani reflected on his own experiences as a former student of Bronx Science, affirming his awareness of both the advantages these schools provide and the limitations of the current admissions process. He contended that the alarming statistics merit serious attention and concern, acknowledging the larger crisis of segregation that affects the city’s educational framework. Mamdani’s overarching goal is to ensure equitable access to resources and support for all public schools, not solely for specialized programs.
While his campaign lacks concrete proposals for reforming the specialized high schools specifically, Mamdani indicated a willingness to revisit previous recommendations aimed at diversifying elementary and middle schools, as suggested during the administration of former Mayor Bill de Blasio. He stressed the importance of addressing external factors impacting education, such as child hunger, asserting that without tackling these issues, efforts to reform the educational system would fall short.
Mamdani’s shift in stance parallels changes seen among other political figures; for instance, Mayor Eric Adams has also moderated his views since taking office. Meanwhile, former Governor Andrew Cuomo has maintained support for the SHSAT as the singular basis for admissions, proposing only limited enhancements to test preparation resources.
In conclusion, substantial changes to the admissions process would likely necessitate approval from the state legislature, which had enacted the law establishing the SHSAT as the admission criterion for three of the eight specialized schools utilizing this system.
Media News Source
