Halloween 1989 marked the assassination attempt on Nicodemo Scarfo Jr. reflecting on this critical event in mob history.
On Halloween night in 1989, South Philadelphia became the focal point of a dramatic mob-related incident that would reverberate through both the local community and law enforcement for decades to come. The notorious Dante & Luigi’s restaurant, located at 10th and Catharine Streets, was the setting for an assassination attempt on Nicodemo Scarfo Jr., the 24-year-old son of the infamous former mob boss Nicodemo “Little Nicky” Scarfo. At the time, the senior Scarfo was serving a prison sentence after a tumultuous five-year reign over the local Mafia, dramatizing the tensions that characterized this era of organized crime.
The evening of the shooting unfolded amid a backdrop of escalating violence within Philadelphia’s Mafia circles, marked by a series of brutal killings during the 1980s. Scarfo Jr. was dining with his cousin and a reputed mob associate when an armed assailant, described as a thin man wearing a yellow Halloween mask, approached their table. Witnesses reported that the gunman fired several shots at point-blank range before fleeing the scene. Scarfo was subsequently left sprawled on the restaurant floor, bleeding and injured but remarkably alive, despite sustaining multiple gunshot wounds.
Scarfo was rushed to Thomas Jefferson University Hospital, where medical professionals emphasized the precarious nature of his injuries. Experts speculated that had the projectiles struck slightly differently, the outcomes could have been fatal. Though Scarfo survived, the attempt on his life highlighted the ongoing power struggles within the Mafia, particularly as previously loyal factions began to fracture.
Law enforcement agencies initially suspected involvement from New York’s Gambino crime family, inferring that the mob’s internal strife had drawn external interest. However, investigations soon indicated that the poorly executed hit bore the hallmark of a local operation. The gun used in the shooting, a MAC-10 fitted with a silencer, was identified as an inferior weapon, further complicating the narrative surrounding the attack.
Months later, the investigation shifted focus toward Joseph Merlino, recognized as a prominent figure among the younger wing of the Mafia known as the “Young Turks.” While Merlino vehemently denied any connection to the assassination attempt, testimonies in later trials implicated him. His alleged anger towards Scarfo, compounded by claims from former mob associates, cast him as a likely suspect.
As of today, the 1989 shooting remains an unsolved case, emblematic of a turbulent chapter in Philadelphia’s mob history that would eventually give way to further conflicts in the 1990s. The incident continues to be referenced in popular culture, including recent documentaries that explore the intricate and perilous world of organized crime in the city. Investigators are still grappling with how a single shooting incident could encapsulate decades of criminal chaos, illustrating the challenges of policing organized crime.
In retrospect, the attempted murder of Nicodemo Scarfo Jr. serves as a stark reminder of the violent legacy of Philadelphia’s Mafia, with its tangled web of loyalty, betrayal, and the ever-present threat of violence. No charges have ever been filed in connection with the shooting, leaving a shadowy past that still intrigues historians and crime enthusiasts alike.
Media News Source.
