New Navigator Needed for NYC Waterfront Development and Management
The New York City Economic Development Corporation (EDC) has faced increasing scrutiny regarding its management of the city’s marine infrastructure and maritime industries. As the recent criticism underscores, there is a growing call for Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani to reevaluate the EDC’s oversight of the waterfront and consider re-establishing a dedicated entity focused on maritime planning and management, akin to historical precedents.
Since its inception in 1991, the EDC has been tasked with overseeing the development of the city’s waterfront. However, many argue that its real estate-centric approach has led to significant neglect of marine infrastructure, allowing the maritime industry, a crucial component of New York’s economic stability and environmental health, to deteriorate. This decline poses risks not only to the economy but also to emergency preparedness and ecological sustainability.
A notable example is the Manhattan Cruise Terminal (MCT), which saw its piers transferred to the EDC in 1998. The EDC’s management has come under fire for leasing two piers to Vornado Realty for a convention center that has seen limited utility. As a result, Pier 92 was declared unusable after a 2019 city inspection, yet despite these challenges, Vornado managed to secure permission to construct a movie studio on Pier 94 in 2023, despite local opposition.
EDC’s commitment to revitalizing Pier 90 and its plans for a massive overhaul of the MCT have drawn concern as well. The proposed modifications would extend the piers to accommodate larger vessels, yet the failure to secure necessary congressional authorization could delay these efforts by up to two years. This proposal, in light of cities like Amsterdam and Venice banning mega cruise ships, raises questions about the strategic direction of New York City’s waterfront development.
On Staten Island, the EDC’s redevelopment efforts have been similarly maligned. Plans announced in 2005 for a shopping mall and an observation wheel at the North Shore have largely failed, with the ambitious 0 million observation wheel project abandoned and reports indicating that the mall remains only half-occupied.
Furthermore, the creation of NYC Ferry in 2015 led to significant financial mismanagement, with a city comptroller’s audit revealing 4 million in unaccounted expenditures. By 2022, the per-passenger subsidy soared to .57, and the private operator of the ferry service declared bankruptcy in 2024.
In a bid to remain relevant, EDC recently introduced a two-day unlimited NYC Ferry pass, which is seen as direct competition to private maritime tour operators who provide fair wages and generate tax revenue.
With the Brooklyn Marine Terminal redevelopment initiated in September, EDC’s plan to establish a Blue Highway hub aims to facilitate the transportation of goods via waterway. However, this ambitious endeavor involves trading a well-maintained state-owned facility for one requiring significant repairs, sparking further criticism of management practices.
Given these ongoing issues, the Mamdani administration is urged to form a professional Maritime Development Corporation (MDC) designed to enhance accountability and operational efficiency. Such an entity could revitalize the maritime legacy of New York City, optimizing waterfront operations, improving workforce training, and fostering resiliency while encouraging public-private partnerships.
New York City has a rich maritime history that spurred its economic rise. Leveraging its waterways for the movement of goods and services in an environmentally conscious manner is critical to reinvigorating its status as an economic powerhouse. The path forward lies in adopting a more strategic and specialized approach to maritime management, ensuring that the city’s waterfront can contribute effectively to its economic and ecological future.
Media News Source
