NYS Parole Board to consider release of drug gang member convicted of murdering rookie cop Edward Byrne in 1988.

The upcoming parole hearing for David McClary, one of four men convicted in the 1988 murder of Police Officer Edward Byrne, is eliciting strong reactions as it approaches its eighth review. McClary, at 59 years old, has consistently faced parole denials since entering prison nearly 36 years ago, largely due to significant opposition from his victim’s family and the Police Benevolent Association (PBA).

Byrne’s murder, which occurred during a troubling period of lawlessness in New York City, has remained a poignant symbol of crime and violence. As a rookie officer, Byrne was tasked with guarding a witness against drug violence when he was tragically ambushed. His assassination not only shocked the city but also prompted calls for more stringent law enforcement and protective measures against gang violence.

This year, McClary’s advocates are making a concerted effort to support his release. They have submitted letters to the Parole Board from various community leaders, including retired correction officials and clergy members, who attest to McClary’s rehabilitative efforts while incarcerated. Supporters emphasize his commitment to engaging in programs aimed at reforming others against crime, showcasing his potential for positive contributions to society.

Conversely, the family of Officer Byrne remains adamant in their opposition to McClary’s release. Kenneth Byrne, the slain officer’s brother and a retired lawyer, articulated that any claims of McClary’s progress cannot diminish the irreversible loss of his brother’s life at the age of 22. Lawrence Byrne, also a former NYPD attorney who passed away in 2020, had long fought against the potential release of the men involved in the murder.

The details of the crime reveal that McClary was the actual shooter, while his accomplices played various roles in the ambush. The order to kill Byrne was issued by drug lord Howard Mason, currently serving time in a federal medical facility. The murder catalyzed a significant political shift toward tougher crime measures and increased federal funding for law enforcement initiatives designed to combat gang-related violence.

Since his initial eligibility for parole in 2013, McClary’s case has taken on complexity amidst varying levels of public support and opposition. Presently, he remains imprisoned at Wende Correctional Facility, alongside one other member of the group, while a third accomplice was released on parole in September 2023.

Opponents, including Queens District Attorney Melinda Katz, have dismissed McClary’s assertions of reform. Katz cited McClary’s infractions and his minimization of his role in Byrne’s murder as grounds for denying parole, reinforcing the perspective that his past actions cannot be overlooked.

As the Parole Board hearing approaches, the discourse surrounding McClary’s potential release illustrates broader societal debates regarding crime, punishment, and rehabilitation. Advocates for McClary highlight transformative changes in his character, emphasizing his potential to reintegrate and contribute positively to the community. However, family members of the victim and law enforcement officials remain resolute in their belief that certain crimes warrant lifelong penalties, illustrating the complexities surrounding justice and redemption in contemporary society.