Probation Commissioner Juanita Holmes faces criticism from First Deputy Mayor Randy Mastro amid ongoing challenges in her role.

Probation Commissioner Juanita Holmes faced significant criticism on Tuesday from First Deputy Mayor Randy Mastro regarding her management of the New York City Department of Probation. This meeting occurred in the context of increased scrutiny over allegations of cronyism and mismanagement within the agency.

Mastro, a prominent figure within Mayor Eric Adams’ administration, did not hold back during the City Hall meeting attended by Deputy Mayor for Public Safety Kaz Daughtry and Holmes’ general counsel, Bridget Hamblin. Sources familiar with the discussions revealed that Mastro emphasized the necessity for Holmes to take immediate corrective action within her agency, underscoring her responsibilities as a commissioner to foster collaborative relationships with her colleagues.

The recent spotlight on Holmes’ leadership has grown intensively, catalyzed by reports revealing troubling dynamics within the Department of Probation. One such story highlighted her decision to sideline Chief Information Officer Razwan Mirza following his refusal to endorse the appointment of her niece, Demmi Slaughter, to a senior technology role. Mirza has since found new employment at City Hall.

An alarming statistic reported by local media indicates a 19% increase in the rearrest rate of probationers during Holmes’ tenure, contradicting her previous assertions about agency performance. Additionally, the city comptroller’s office recently limited the agency’s procurement capabilities after it reportedly evaded regulations to purchase a taxpayer-funded SUV costing ,000.

In addition to the recent personnel turmoil, Holmes has taken steps to restrict communication within her department. She issued warnings to staff regarding contact with the media, prohibited the use of thumb drives in the office, and mandated authorization for access to the agency’s human resources section. These measures align with troubling reports from a City Council hearing held on July 28, where employees expressed significant discontent regarding Holmes’ leadership practices. Complaints included accusations of favoritism in hiring practices, particularly regarding the promotion of friends and relatives at the expense of experienced staff members.

Following these developments, Council Member Sandy Nurse has called for an independent audit of the Department of Probation, a suggestion that Holmes’ aides have stated she would welcome.

Holmes has been serving as the Probation Commissioner since her appointment by Mayor Adams in March 2023. Following the meeting with Mastro, sources indicated that a more hands-on approach was planned for Daughtry, who is expected to mediate interactions between Holmes and her staff.

In a related announcement, sources confirmed that former NBA player Jayson Williams withdrew as the keynote speaker for the upcoming American Probation and Parole Association national conference scheduled for August 24-27 in Times Square. While the reasons behind his decision remain unclear, it has generated disappointment within the agency, particularly given its significant involvement in the conference, including planned events such as a Circle Line cruise and an anniversary celebration that coincides with Williams’ original speaking invitation. The APPA subsequently confirmed that attorney Jessica Jackson would replace Williams at the event.

This situation at the Department of Probation raises critical questions regarding agency accountability and effective leadership in managing complex social issues within New York City. As the circumstances continue to unfold, the public will be closely monitoring developments related to Holmes’ tenure and overall agency performance.