Shark attacks at the Jersey Shore in July 1916 resulted in fatalities, influencing the creation of the film ‘Jaws.’
In the summer of 1975, the cinematic landscape was irrevocably changed with the release of a film that introduced a menacing great white shark to audiences. However, long before the fictional narrative of “Jaws” captivated millions, a series of real events transpired along the Jersey Shore in 1916 that would forever alter public perception of sharks.
During the summer of 1916, five shark attacks occurred in New Jersey within a remarkably short span of just 12 days, resulting in four fatalities and one serious injury. This unprecedented series of incidents sent shockwaves through the nation, as the American public was largely unaccustomed to such violent encounters with marine life. At the time, the notion of shark attacks was more a topic of fishermen’s tales than common reality, and the mere existence of species like the great white was largely relegated to folklore.
The first attack took place on July 1, 1916, in Beach Haven, where a 23-year-old University of Pennsylvania graduate named Charles Vansant was viciously bitten by a shark while swimming. The horrific event unfolded as Vansant played with a dog in the surf, but within moments, he became the first victim, succumbing to severe injuries inflicted when the shark tore into his thigh, severing his femoral artery. The efforts of his physician father to save him were tragically in vain.
A mere five days later, a second shark attack occurred in Spring Lake, approximately 54 miles north, where hotel bellman Charles Bruder was swimming when he too fell victim to a shark. In a grim twist of fate, Bruder was unable to survive his injuries and died while being transported by a rescue boat.
The situation escalated further with additional attacks on July 12, which happened not in the ocean but rather 10 miles inland at Matawan Creek. During this incident, Lester Stillwell, a young boy swimming with friends, was attacked. When 24-year-old Stanley Fisher attempted to rescue him, he too became prey to the shark. Tragically, both boys lost their lives, while the only survivor of the summer was 14-year-old Joseph Dunn, who endured extensive injuries and remained silent about the traumatic events for years.
In response to these alarming attacks, public hysteria gripped both the local communities and the entire nation. The fear of sharks deterred many beachgoers from entering the water, fundamentally altering summer recreation along the coast. Notably, an eight-foot juvenile great white shark was eventually captured in Raritan Bay, with human remains reportedly discovered in its stomach, affirming the disturbing reality of the attacks.
This summer of 1916 not only reshaped the coastal experiences of those living in New Jersey but also inspired a cultural shift in how sharks were perceived. The true events of that fateful summer contributed to the narrative that would later be immortalized in Peter Benchley’s novel “Jaws,” and subsequent film adaptation by Steven Spielberg, which solidified the shark’s status as an emblem of terror in American culture.
These historical events remind us of the fine line between nature and humanity, showcasing how a series of tragic incidents can provoke widespread fear and change societal norms. As summer approaches, the legacy of these attacks continues to resonate, provoking curiosity and trepidation in equal measure.
Media News Source