Two individuals convicted for the vigilante murder of a Newark teenager.
Two residents of Newark, New Jersey, have been convicted for the vigilante-style murder of a teenager, following a series of criminal activities that escalated into a fatal encounter two years ago. On Tuesday, authorities confirmed the convictions of Felicia Bynum, 51, and James Headen, 33, for the first-degree murder of 17-year-old Kiman Mays, who was shot and killed on August 17, 2023, in Newark.
Court documents reveal that Mays, along with two accomplices, Lonnell Carruthers, 29, and Yusuf Julious, 21, had been allegedly committing a series of robberies throughout the city on that fateful day. Witnesses indicate that Bynum and Headen observed the criminal activities and made the decision to intervene personally. As law enforcement officials later detailed, their pursuit of Mays and his associates culminated in a vehicular collision and a subsequent armed confrontation.
The events turned tragic when the encounter escalated into a shootout, resulting in Mays’ death and injuries to Carruthers. The case has raised significant concerns about the ramifications of taking justice into one’s own hands, with Essex County Assistant Prosecutor Justin Edwab emphasizing that vigilante justice is fundamentally flawed and cannot be justified.
In addition to first-degree murder, Bynum and Headen were also found guilty of first-degree conspiracy to commit murder, second-degree conspiracy to commit aggravated assault, and multiple weapons offenses. They are facing a prison sentence ranging from 30 years to life, with their sentencing scheduled for September 15, 2025.
Meanwhile, Carruthers and Julious, who were apprehended alongside Mays at the time of the incident, still face a range of charges that include robbery, conspiracy to commit robbery, receiving stolen property, and weapons offenses. The ongoing legal proceedings against them further illustrate the complexities of crime and retribution within the community.
This case underscores broader societal issues around crime prevention, community safety, and the legal consequences of unauthorized acts of justice. As discussions continue around the implications of such vigilante actions, the judicial system must navigate the impactful consequences of these tragic confrontations.
As the situation unfolds, the community remains attentive to the legal outcomes and the potential changes in policies addressing crime intervention and public safety in Newark.
Media News Source
