Critics describe ‘Wicked: For Good’ as more numbing than magical in recent reviews.
The film “Wicked: For Good,” directed by Jon M. Chu, is set to open in theaters, continuing the cinematic adaptation of the Broadway sensation derived from Gregory Maguire’s novel, which serves as a prequel to “The Wizard of Oz.” This sequel marks the second installment in the two-part adaptation of the hit musical, bringing back stars Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande in their acclaimed roles as Elphaba, the Wicked Witch of the West, and Glinda the Good, respectively.
Though the film arrives almost a year after the release of its predecessor, early reviews indicate a mixed reception from critics. As of now, “Wicked: For Good” boasts a 72% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes and a score of 61 on Metacritic, suggesting a level of critical division. In contrast, the first installment received an 88% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, along with a score of 73 on Metacritic, reflecting a stronger consensus among critics regarding its effectiveness.
While some reviewers herald the film as a surprisingly satisfying conclusion to the story, others have pointed out flaws, notably in the execution of its second act, which some have described as “breathlessly stretched-out.” Critics from Slant Magazine expressed disappointment, stating that “Wicked: For Good” lacks emotional resonance, with the film failing to evoke the same transformative experience offered by its stage counterpart.
The Boston Globe echoed similar sentiments, characterizing the film as “more of the same, only darker,” and observing that even devoted fans might find it wanting compared to the first film. The Associated Press noted that the film’s quest for maximum emotional impact often overshadows the actors’ performances, leaving little room for subtlety or genuine feeling.
Despite the criticisms regarding the film’s narrative pacing and emotional depth, Erivo and Grande have garnered praise for their performances. Critics have acknowledged their chemistry, which enhances the film’s climactic moments. Various outlets have noted that the duo’s robust portrayals help bring life to the film, with The Guardian awarding it a strong rating and commending Erivo’s performance.
Overall, while the consensus appears to lean toward disappointment with certain aspects of “Wicked: For Good,” fans of the franchise may still find enjoyment in the concluding chapter of this beloved tale. As the film premieres, the hopes of both audiences and critics remain high for what is expected to be a visually stunning and musical experience, even if it does not entirely fulfill the lofty expectations set by its predecessor.
