Brooklyn man receives life sentence for murdering drug dealer and concealing body parts in a refrigerator.
A Brooklyn man has been sentenced to life imprisonment for the brutal murder and dismemberment of his former roommate, Kawsheen Gelzer, in a chilling case that has drawn significant media attention. Nicholas McGee, 48, was convicted of first-degree murder following a harrowing trial that revealed the gruesome details of the crime committed in March 2022.
The incident transpired in McGee’s Flatbush apartment, where he and his wife, Heather Stines, lived. According to court documents, the relationship between the couple and Gelzer was marked by drug exchanges and sexual favors, forming a volatile blend of tension and desperation. The situation escalated after Gelzer reportedly requested sexual favors from Stines, which she refused, leading to a violent confrontation when Gelzer fell asleep on their couch.
On March 25, 2022, an enraged McGee confronted Gelzer, demanding drugs in what has been described as a fit of rage over perceived disrespect. Following a series of aggressive altercations, McGee resorted to a kitchen knife, fatally stabbing Gelzer multiple times while using a hammer to further inflict harm. After Gelzer succumbed to his injuries, McGee disposed of the body by dismembering it and placing the remains in the couple’s refrigerator and freezer.
The grisly crime was uncovered on January 20, 2024, when police received an anonymous tip suggesting the presence of a body in the couple’s residence. Upon investigation, officers discovered Gelzer’s severed head in the refrigerator, leading to McGee’s subsequent arrest in a separate location in Virginia.
In court, Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice John Hecht emphasized the severity of McGee’s actions, ultimately sentencing him to life without the possibility of parole. McGee’s case has raised concerns regarding public safety and the implications of drug-related violence within the community.
Additionally, Stines, who faced charges related to the concealment of the corpse, has also been implicated in the crime. Her role reportedly involves aiding McGee in the cover-up, as the couple continued to evade scrutiny while maintaining their drug habits through retail thefts.
Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez condemned the heinous act, noting the brutality displayed by McGee in both taking Gelzer’s life and violating the sanctity of the deceased. This case serves as a stark reminder of the tragic consequences associated with drug addiction and violence. The community is left grappling with the aftermath, as the judicial system seeks to address the ramifications of this disturbing crime.
The implications of this case extend beyond the courtroom, prompting discussions on issues such as mental health, drug abuse, and domestic violence. As authorities work to prevent such violent incidents, the community remains vigilant, reflecting on the tragic events that unfolded in this Brooklyn apartment.
