AI actor Tilly Norwood sparks controversy in Hollywood.
In recent developments within the entertainment industry, the emergence of Tilly Norwood—a character described as the first artificial intelligence (AI) actor—has ignited significant controversy. Created by the innovative company Xicoia, which identifies itself as the world’s first AI talent studio, Norwood’s journey into Hollywood has not been received warmly by many within the community.
Tilly Norwood’s debut was spearheaded by Eline Van der Velden, a Dutch producer and comedian, who has actively promoted the character at various industry events, most notably the Zurich Summit, a prominent gathering on the sidelines of the Zurich Film Festival. During this event, Van der Velden reported that several talent agencies were expressing interest in signing Norwood, raising alarms among actors, guild members, and advocates for creative rights.
The backlash was swift and pronounced. Organizations like the Screen Actors Guild (SAG) promptly condemned the notion of AI participating as a competitor in the acting sphere. In a recent statement, the guild emphasized that creativity ought to remain a fundamentally human endeavor, clarifying that Norwood, as a product of artificial constructs, lacks real-life experience, emotional depth, and genuine storytelling ability. The guild highlighted the ethical implications of creating characters through AI technology, particularly addressing concerns regarding the potential unauthorized use of human performers’ likenesses.
Such concerns are not unfounded, especially in light of the industry’s recent labor disputes. The discussions surrounding AI were pivotal elements of negotiations that culminated in the SAG-AFTRA strike, which concluded in late 2023, introducing specific protections for actors against the exploitation of their images and performances by AI. There exists an underlying apprehension regarding the long-term effects of introducing AI in roles traditionally held by humans.
Despite the controversies, Van der Velden maintains that the creation of Tilly Norwood represents an artistic endeavor rather than an attempt to replace human actors. Over the course of her promotion, Norwood has accumulated over 33,000 followers on social media, where the character is portrayed engaging in day-to-day activities such as shopping and preparing for screen tests.
Experts in the field, such as Dominic Lees, an associate professor specializing in filmmaking and AI, have noted that the current reaction to Norwood raises questions about the broader implications of AI’s role in the arts. Nonetheless, the technology has yet to achieve the level of believability that would make AI characters widely acceptable to audiences.
With Hollywood grappling with the evolving impact of artificial intelligence, the discourse surrounding Tilly Norwood has become a critical convergence of ethics, creativity, and the future of performing arts. As the debate continues, stakeholders in the industry remain vigilant about the precedent that AI actors might set for traditional practices and the protection of human creativity.
Media News Source
